Skip to content
Free shipping within Australia for all orders over $99 AUD
Free shipping within Australia for all orders over $99 AUD

Top 5 Eyeliner Choices For 2025

Our editors’ top picks for bold, precise lines and flawless definition.

See Products Last Reviewed: 31 January 2026
Eye Pencil

Eye Pencil

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Jojoba Eye Pencil

Jojoba Eye Pencil

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Natural Eye Pencil

Natural Eye Pencil

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Eye and Lip Definer

Eye and Lip Definer

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Eye Pencils

Eye Pencils

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Vegan Eyeliner Pencil

Vegan Eyeliner Pencil

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Eco duo sharpener

Eco duo sharpener

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Axiology Balmie

Axiology Balmie

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Eyeliner

Eyeliner

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Liquid Eyeliner (Black)

Liquid Eyeliner (Black)

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Mineral Goddess Eye Liners

Mineral Goddess Eye Liners

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Axiology Balmie Highlighters

Axiology Balmie Highlighters

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Forte High Definition Eye Liner

Forte High Definition Eye Liner

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Gel Liner Onyx

Gel Liner Onyx

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Mineral Goddess Intensity

Mineral Goddess Intensity

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Clean Beauty Babe Cosmetics Bag

Clean Beauty Babe Cosmetics Bag

Buy Now

4.9/5 (8 reviews)

Price $27.20 $37.00 $22.00 $45.00 $29.60 $39.95 $18.00 $25.00 $25.00 $45.00 $30.00 $25.00 $33.95 $58.00 $40.00 $19.95
Key Ingredients Marula oil, Jojoba oil Jojoba oil, Shea butter, natural waxes Jojoba oil, Shea butter, Vitamin E Organic oils, natural waxes Organic Coconut oil, Carnauba Wax, Vitamin E Natural oils, waxes, Vitamin E Sustainable materials Natural oils, waxes, mineral pigments Organic oils, waxes Natural pigments, Aloe Vera, Vitamin E Natural waxes, mineral pigments Natural oils, mineral pigments Natural waxes, oils Natural oils, waxes Natural waxes, mineral pigments Eco-friendly material
Primary Benefits Smooth application, long-lasting, suitable for sensitive eyes Nourishing, smooth application, long-lasting Gentle, easy application, suitable for sensitive eyes Precision defining, dual-use eyes and lips Smooth glide, intense pigmentation Vegan, soft application Sharpens precisely Multipurpose, hydrating Precision application, long-lasting Easy application, intense black Highly pigmented, creamy texture Multipurpose highlighter, hydrating Rich pigmentation, precise definition Smooth gel formulation, precise definition Intense pigmentation, creamy Practical storage for cosmetics
Suitable Skin Types All skin types, sensitive All skin types All skin types, sensitive All skin types All skin types, sensitive All skin types N/A All skin types All skin types All skin types All skin types, sensitive All skin types All skin types All skin types All skin types, sensitive N/A
Size / Volume 1.2 g 1.1 g 1.14 g 1.08 g 1.2 g 1.1 g One Size 3.4 g 1 g 3.5 ml 1.2 g 3.4 g 1.1 g 3 g 1.2 g One Size

Choosing The Right Eyeliners

Key Factors To Consider

💧

Skin Type Compatibility

Choose a face wash specifically formulated for your skin type—whether dry, oily, combination, or sensitive.

🌿

Ingredients

Look for gentle, non-irritating ingredients. Avoid harsh sulfates and alcohol if you have sensitive skin.

🛡️

pH Balance

A good face wash should maintain your skin's natural pH balance (around 5.5) to protect your skin barrier.

Types Of Moisturisers

💧

Gel Moisturisers

Lightweight, water-based formulas ideal for oily, combination, or acne-prone skin. They hydrate effectively without clogging pores or leaving residue.

🌿

Cream Moisturisers

Richer, thicker textures perfect for dry or mature skin. These moisturisers deeply nourish and restore hydration, protecting skin from dryness and irritation.

🛡️

Oil Moisturisers

Intense hydration options best suited for very dry or sensitive skin. These moisturisers help replenish the skin’s natural barrier and lock in moisture.

How to Choose the Perfect Eyeliner for Your Look

Essential Features to Look For

When selecting an eyeliner, prioritise products with a formulation suited to your needs. Ingredients such as Vitamin E and jojoba oil help nourish and condition the delicate skin around your eyes. Additionally, waterproof formulas containing polymers and waxes provide long-lasting, smudge-resistant wear. Eyeliners enriched with soothing elements like chamomile extract are ideal for sensitive eyes.

Benefits Beyond Definition

Great eyeliners not only enhance your eyes but also protect and nourish your skin. Some formulas incorporate beneficial skincare ingredients such as hyaluronic acid or peptides that hydrate and condition the skin, preventing dryness or irritation. Regular use can enhance the overall appearance of your eyes, making them look brighter and more youthful.

Matching Eyeliners to Your Style

Your personal style significantly influences your ideal eyeliner choice:

  1. Classic Look: Traditional pencil eyeliners are perfect for creating soft, natural lines and are easy to smudge for subtle definition.
  2. Dramatic Look: Liquid eyeliners with precise felt-tip or brush applicators allow sharp, bold lines ideal for cat-eye styles and graphic looks.
  3. Everyday Look: Retractable twist-up pencils offer convenience, ease of use, and versatility, ideal for daily wear.
  4. Waterproof Needs: Gel eyeliners, known for their rich pigmentation and durability, are excellent for long-lasting wear and humid conditions.

Considering Packaging and Application

Packaging matters when selecting an eyeliner. Pen-style applicators provide precision and ease of use, especially for beginners. Pot eyeliners require brushes and offer more versatility but may need extra practice. Ensure the cap or packaging provides an airtight seal to avoid drying out. Travel-friendly and compact designs are preferable for those constantly on-the-go.

Personalising Your Eyeliner Choice

Choosing the perfect eyeliner also depends on your individual preferences and lifestyle. Consider the texture—matte, glossy, or metallic finishes can significantly affect your final look. If you have a busy lifestyle, opt for quick-drying, smudge-resistant formulas that withstand daily activities without frequent touch-ups.

Additional Features and Considerations

Some eyeliners come with additional benefits, like built-in sharpeners, smudging tips, or lash-enhancing ingredients. Eyeliners formulated specifically for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers ensure comfort throughout the day. Hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested products provide peace of mind, especially if you have allergy-prone or sensitive skin.

Importance of Regular Care

Consistent eyeliner application complements your beauty routine, enhancing your eye shape and overall makeup look. Proper care, including sharpening pencils regularly and securely capping liquid liners, maintains product effectiveness and hygiene. Establishing these simple habits ensures optimal performance and enduring results.

Founder photo

A Note From Erin

Why I Stand By These Products

When I set out to create a trusted eyeliner selection, it was guided by the belief that what we apply near our eyes matters deeply—not just for beauty, but for eye health and comfort. Too often, conventional eyeliners contain harsh chemicals, irritating fragrances, or drying ingredients that compromise our delicate eye area.

I aimed to curate something genuinely better. Every eyeliner featured here has been personally tested and chosen not just for their exceptional performance and smooth application but because they are gentle, reliable, and truly enhance your beauty routine. Whether you're after bold, dramatic lines, subtle definition, or something versatile in-between, these formulas deliver precision, lasting wear, and care for your eyes.

Each eyeliner undergoes rigorous evaluation for ease of use, pigment intensity, durability, and safety. I prioritise nourishing ingredients—such as vitamin E, jojoba oil, and soothing extracts—combined with smudge-proof, ophthalmologist-tested formulations that protect and enhance your natural beauty safely and effectively.

These aren’t merely eyeliners—they’re daily essentials, confidence boosters, and integral parts of your beauty regimen. I hope you discover your perfect match, crafted to make your eyes stand out beautifully, safely, and confidently every single day.

Thousands Of Reviews
Clean Sustainable Products
Only The Best Brands